Project FarmReviews

Disclaimer: The information provided in this review is for entertainment purposes only. Product performance may vary, and actual results may differ from those depicted in our review. We do not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information presented, and we encourage you to conduct your own research before making any purchasing decisions. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Harbor Freight’s Tarp Shocked Me! 1-Year Test, 14 Tarps! Wow!

Todd's Picks

Best Performance

Top Scores Across All Tests

CAMPMAC Super HD

Average Finish: 1.4

Purchased for: $50

Made In: China

Search on Amazon

Waterproof, UV resistant, tear resistant. Heaviest tarp at 6,710 g.

Extremely durable but very expensive

Best Value

Excellent Overall Protection

Rugged Rhino

Average Finish: 4

Purchased for: $26

Made In: China

Search on Amazon

5 mil thickness. Waterproof and weather resistant. Weighs 1,196 g.

Great balance of cost and performance

Runner-up

Very Durable Mid-Price Option

CAMPMAC HD

Average Finish: 2.6

Purchased for: $22

Made In: China

Search on Amazon

12 mil thickness, metal grommets every 20 in. Weighs 2,008 g.

Strong UV and wind resistance

NamePrice ($)Price Per Piece ($)Made InAverage FinishLinkContent
CAMPMAC Super HD
$50.00
$
China
1.4
Search on Amazon
Waterproof, UV resistant, tear resistant. Heaviest tarp at 6,710 g.
CAMPMAC HD
$22.00
$
China
2.6
Search on Amazon
12 mil thickness, metal grommets every 20 in. Weighs 2,008 g.
Patiobay
$24.00
$
China
2.9
Search on Amazon
14 mil thickness, brass grommets, UV resistant. Weighs 2,190 g.
Rugged Rhino
$26.00
$13.00
China
4
Search on Amazon
5 mil thickness. Waterproof and weather resistant. Weighs 1,196 g.
King-A-Ma-Jigs Pro
$20.00
$
China
5
Search on Amazon
10 mil thickness, double laminated, grommets every 18 in. Weighs 1,956 g.
Cartman
$26.00
$13.00
China
6
Search on Amazon
8 mil thickness. Waterproof, tear resistant, UV resistant. Weighs 1,094 g.
Amazon Basics
$23.00
$
China
6
Search on Amazon
Designed for camping, ripstop fabric, reinforced corners. Weighs 1,038 g.
Harbor Freight Extreme Duty
$18.00
$
China
8
Search on Amazon
12 mil thickness, 14x14 weave, very heavy. Weighs 2,130 g.
Zuperia
$45.00
$
China
8
Search on Amazon
Waterproof and breathable cloth-like material. Weighs 4,192 g.
Harbor Freight Light Duty
$8.00
$
China
9
Search on Amazon
4 mil thickness. Rust-resistant grommets, rot and tear resistant. Weighs 1,048 g.
Grizzly Tarps
$16.00
$
Vietnam
12
Search on Amazon
5 mil thickness, 8x8 weave. Waterproof and washable. Weighs 796 g.
Foremost Dry Top
$9.00
$
Vietnam
13
Search on Amazon
7 mil thickness. Rust-resistant aluminum grommets. Weighs 878 g.
VEVOR
$12.00
$
China
14
Search on Amazon
5 mil thickness, UV protection, strong waterproofing. Weighs 754 g.
Foremost Cut Size
$13.00
$
Vietnam
14
Search on Amazon
Rip resistant woven fabric. Weighs 702 g.

Price comparison of all 14 tarp brands tested.

Overall ranking based on combined performance across all tests.

Pull force required to tear out a grommet from a brand-new tarp.

Force needed to worsen an existing rip in a UV-damaged section.

Force required to puncture a new tarp with a sharp pick.