The Pink Stuff finished on top with a combined score of 2.4, taking the coffee
and mustard tests outright and placing second on grape juice, all for $6 a
bottle. Its one soft spot was the graphite motor oil swatch, where it managed
only tenth. As a general-purpose pretreatment for food and drink stains it was
the most consistent thing in the group.
On value the argument goes to Shout: $4 for 22 ounces works out to 18 cents an
ounce, the cheapest per ounce here, and its combined score of 3.3 sits within a
hair of OxiClean Max Force Spray at 3.2. OxiClean Max Force Spray is the pick
where oil and pigment are the usual problem, since it won both the graphite
motor oil and the grape juice tests. Spray 'n Wash is cheaper still at $3 a
bottle and won soy sauce outright, and Tide Rescue came second on the motor oil
swatches.
Spending more bought less. De-Solv-It at $20 finished fourteenth on coffee, and
Attitude at $16 never cracked the top six on any stain. At the other end, a hot
wash with a detergent pod and nothing else placed fourteenth on four of the five
ranked stains, so pretreating is clearly worth the trouble. The homebrew mix of
roughly two parts hydrogen peroxide to one part Dawn was second on soy sauce and
third on coffee for pennies, though it was also the only treatment that left a
faint light patch on a red cotton shirt, so it is worth keeping away from
colours that matter.