The SK is the pair to buy. It finished best overall in the scoring,
cutting a 16-penny nail at 66 lb — the lowest force in the test — a
number 10 deck screw at 137 lb, and a drill bit shaft at 187 lb, and its
handles closed without registering on the force meter straight out of the box.
At $18 it is the third-cheapest pair here and the clear budget pick under $20.
The Channellock finished second overall, pairing
75 lb on the nail and 140 lb on the deck screw with USA manufacturing for
under $30, and the Wiha was third at 4.2 thanks to a dynamic joint that
switches between a wide 4.92 mm opening and a 2.04 mm high-leverage setting —
good for the best deck screw result in the test at 117 lb. The real bargain,
though, is the $13 WORKPRO: it cut the drill bit at 158 lb, less force than
anything else here, and needed just 68 lb on the nail. Its handles are stiff
at 2.6 lb, which is the one thing that keeps it out of the top spot.
Durability is a separate question from cutting force, and the KNIPEX owns it:
it cut clean through a 3/16 inch hex key at 531 lb and came out in relatively
good shape, something only one other pair has managed in five years of this
test. The Engineer is nearly as tough at 528 lb but poorly set up for
leverage, needing 121 lb on the nail and 259 lb on the screw. Spending more
buys surprisingly little: the $70 GEDORE needed 332 lb on the drill bit, the
$78 Snap-On was beaten on every cut by pliers costing a quarter as much and
had the stiffest handles at 5.5 lb, and the $30 Crescent broke apart on the
drill bit. The $10 Utoolmart is best avoided outright — a nail damaged its
edges and a deck screw destroyed them.