On raw protection the G&F is not close to being beaten. At $2.80 a pair it won abrasion at 61 passes, impact at 0.59 mm of dowel damage, and puncture at 8.95 lb — a puncture figure nearly two and a half times the second-place Carhartt — and its 4.3 seconds of cut resistance was respectable for a glove that makes no cut-resistance claim at all. The catch is the hand: at 5.9 lb of finger bend force it is one of the stiffest gloves here, and comfort was assessed as poor. If the work is all about durability and value, this is the pick.
The pick for overall value and performance is the $10 WZQH. It took top grades in four of the seven graded categories, finishing third for impact at 1.51 mm of dowel damage, 23 abrasion passes, and 4.9 lb of grip, all for a third of what the top-priced gloves cost. Spending roughly $20 on the Toolant buys back most of the comfort the G&F gives up — 1.8 lb of bend force against the G&F's 5.9 — while still returning 26 abrasion passes, third-best in the field, and 5.62 seconds of cut resistance, behind only the HexArmor and the Kinco.
Price is a poor guide here, and the specific claims are worth checking against the specific numbers. Comfort, assessed subjectively, went to the Superior Glove and the Mechanix at a rating of 1.5, with the Palmer close behind at 2 — but the Superior Glove and West Chester were the first two to wear through in abrasion at six and seven passes, and the Mechanix was the easiest fingertip to puncture at 1.73 lb. Impact claims fared no better: the Magid and the NoCry both advertise back-of-hand impact protection and both let through more dowel damage than any other glove. For sharp-object work the HexArmor and the Kinco are the two that genuinely resist cutting, at 9.1 and 9.4 seconds, and the West Chester is the one to reach for when grip matters most, at 7.7 lb.