The Starrett is the best overall caliper in this comparison, finishing with a
3.6 average across the graded categories. It was perfect at every position on
the 1-2-3 block, tied for second in slide-force consistency at 36 g of
variance, placed third for smoothness, shuts off automatically after 30
minutes, and runs the higher-capacity battery. Its one real omission is the
absolute linear scale — surprising at $144. The Fowler and Mitutoyo tied for
second at 3.7, and both do offer the absolute linear scale, which remembers
the jaw position between power cycles so the caliper never needs re-zeroing;
neither, however, powers down automatically.
For value, the Werka at $27 is the clear pick. It performed almost as well
as the premium brands — a 36 g slide-force variance matching the Starrett,
0.0005 in total error on the gauge block, and 0.0025 in on depth — and it
powers down automatically when idle. If it's unavailable, the $25 Neiko is a
strong alternate with an even smoother feel (second only to the Mitutoyo) and
a near-identical gauge-block score. The $72 INSIZE deserves a mention too: it
had the steadiest beam in the lineup and was the only caliper to nail all
three depth measurements exactly.
A few buying notes. Only the Quinn, Fowler, and Mitutoyo offer the absolute
linear scale. Calipers running a CR2032 battery — including the Kynup, S&F,
INSIZE, and Fowler — carry roughly twice the capacity of the LR44 cells in
most budget models, though the Mitutoyo compensates for its LR44 with
low-power circuitry. On the caution side, the S&F was the only caliper that
would not consistently return to zero after cleaning and re-zeroing, and the
$7-$10 tier has real limits: the Adoric and Pittsburgh both have outside tips
too wide to reach into a narrow groove, and the Adoric's two-decimal display
can't resolve the fine differences the rest of the field reports.