Taking all four tests together, OxiClean finished on top:
second on the oil-soaked cloth, first on oil-stained concrete, and
mid-pack on hardened grease. Zep was close behind in second place overall and
was the single best product on the cloth test, which is the one that most
resembles cleaning an oily engine bay. At $12 against OxiClean's $23, Zep gets
to nearly the same place for about half the money, and both are usable at full
strength straight from the bottle.
Super Clean is the value pick. It is the cheapest product here at $6, the only
one that arrives ready to use in its own spray bottle, and it finished third
overall. It also dissolved hardened grease better than anything else and tied
for the best mildew rating of 1. Judged only on the three tests that do not
involve cotton cloth, Super Clean comes out first, ahead of Spitfire at 3.00 and Oil Eater at 3.33 — so for greasy parts,
engine work, and siding, it is hard to justify spending more.
Two findings are worth carrying into a purchase. Oil and grease behave like
separate jobs: Simple Green Aircraft placed second on concrete and 12th of 13
on grease, and Purple Power was third on concrete and 11th on grease, so a
product picked on one result can disappoint badly on the other. And badly
stained concrete does not come back — two rounds of degreaser and a pressure
washer left every block far darker than the light gray it started as, which
argues for treating a driveway spill quickly rather than expecting any of these
to undo an old one. Dawn Ultra Platinum, cheap and already under the sink, was
beaten by nearly every dedicated degreaser in the group, and Goof Off's
last-place finishes came on fabric and grease rather than the concrete it is
built for.