The Winix at $180 is the winner. It won by being the
only machine to lead both hard filtration tests: 115 particles left in the
sealed smoke box, the lowest in the lineup, and 3.9 million particles removed
from a 240 sq ft room in 30 minutes, about 200,000 more than the Levoit 200
and 700,000 more than the Blueair. It also swept the dust test to a flat zero.
It is not the airflow champion — 270 CFM puts it third — which is the whole
point: filter efficiency, not fan size, decided this test. The one real
drawback is noise, at 63.1 dB on the highest speed.
For a medium-size room the pick is the Levoit 300 at about $100. It cleared the
smoke box in 32 seconds, faster than anything except the Coway, Dyson, and
Levoit 200, finished with 310 particles, hit zero in the dust test, and pulled
2.7 million particles out of the room test — better than purifiers costing two
and three times as much. It is loud on high at 64.8 dB and draws 58.95 W, so
it is best run a step down. In small spaces the Levoit Mini is the one to buy:
at $50 it moved 31 CFM, cut the dust count to 5,604 where the AroEve left
7,239, and used only 7.62 W.
The Coway and Dyson tied for second overall, and the
gap between them is price. The Coway at $229 produced the most airflow in the
test at 293 CFM and cleared visible smoke fastest at 24 seconds, but it draws
75.7 W and runs at 64.4 dB. The Dyson at $1,200 is quieter than every large
purifier here at 48.7 dB, moved the most air on low at 83 CFM, and finished
second in the smoke box at 135 particles — genuinely excellent, and roughly
seven times the price of the machine that beat it. At the bottom, the $32
Fulminare should be avoided outright: it never cleared the smoke box in three
minutes, left 51,000 dust particles where most units left none, and barely
moved the needle in the room test. Below roughly $100 the compact units are
desk-side accessories, not room purifiers.